Welcome to our Wiki Article Spotlight!

So this is a bit unusual. It's a public Wiki article about moderation guidelines for our forums:

Forum Moderation Guide: Managing Posts and Threads: Marking Answers

Anthony Mann and I wrote that article (based on existing content). It's part of a larger series about forum moderation.

Here's Anthony's profile:

Anthony_Mann's avatar
 

So why are we making forum moderation guidelines so public?

Well, so that they're easy to access and to update, of course!

If you're an Answerer, Moderator, Administrator, or Owner of an MSDN or TechNet forum, then we ask that you follow these answering guidelines...

  1. Propose an answer first. Give the Asker/OP a chance to select the right answer.
  2. After proposing an answer, wait one week (7 days). This gives the OP more than enough time to return. More often than not, the OP will not mark an answer and will not reply again. After waiting the week, then mark the answer. The Asker/OP is your client, and you want to help him and make him happy. Many OPs have gotten angry when Moderators mark answers without waiting a few days (waiting 7 days sets a clear message that the Asker/OP is the client and that you are patient). Plus the people who answer the questions get 5 more points (15 Recognition Points instead of 10) if the Asker/OP is the one who marks the reply as an answer. One exception (to proposing first) is if the thread hasn’t been responded to for over 6 months (you’re cleaning up a forum). But even then, it’s better to propose first if you’re uncertain about an answer.
  3. Use caution when marking a 3rd-Party solution or link as the answer. We do not want to point people to an untested tool that could hack someone’s computer, but certainly a reference to a known OEM site to download a driver is acceptable. An example would be an answer that points users to a specific Dell driver on the Dell Web site.
  4. Ask the OP to mark answers (if it makes sense). If the OP returns and says thank you, but does not mark the answer, then first reply with a polite request for them to mark the answer. I use, “If your question is answered, please mark a post someone made as the answer.” And when you do that, if your post is the answer, then I’d ask someone else to make the “please mark a reply as the answer” request (otherwise it looks like you’re saying, “give me points by marking my answer”). This actually works most of the time (if they already thanked you, then they come back and mark it). It means that many times new OPs don't know about the marking answers feature.
  5. Try not to mark your own answers (this is why we try to build a team of Moderators and Answerers, so that you don’t have to do this). I recommend that you get the email addresses of your forum team, and then send out emails to them when you need them to propose or mark your answers. Then just do your best to respect each other’s’ opinions when they conflict. You can still mark your own answers, but make sure you follow #1 and #2 first. For a clear debate on this topic, see the TNWiki article, Whether or Not You Should Self Propose an Answer in an MSDN or TechNet Forum.
  6. Try to propose and mark the answers of others on your team. For example, if someone else partially answered a question, and you want to add to it, then propose both answers, not just your own. And when it comes time to marking answers, make sure you mark the other person’s answer as well (not just your own). You should be willing to unpropose and unmark your answer when appropriate. It’s a team effort.
  7. You should unmark answers VERY rarely (and communicate first). Obviously unmark answers if you accidentally marked them as answers but didn’t mean to (try not to do that). If you unmark an answer that was marked by the Asker/OP, then you’re being disrespectful to them. They are the client in this scenario. You’re trying to help them, not fight them. So instead you can propose additional answers, mark additional answers, or explain in a reply why you think another post is an additional answer. Another scenario where you might want to unmark an answer is if another Answerer/Moderator marked something as an answer but was wrong (the reply is incorrect and doesn’t help in any way or the Asker came back later and said that it wasn’t an answer). If the Moderator has a reason for proposing/marking an answer, you need to discuss that reason before unmarking answers. Do not start a marking/unmarking answers war. Instead, email the Answerer/Moderator and explain what you want to do first. It’s always better to move slowly and carefully. Think of this as a marathon and not a sprint… communicate first and act second.
  8. Use the Vote As Helpful button whenever any post is helpful. It makes a much more positive, kind, and giving environment. Plus everyone in that environment gets more Recognition Points (5 points with each vote), and so more people then want to be part of that environment (so it helps you grow and care for your community).

Personal request: If you see any process or other body of detailed, helpful information that you or someone else writes that you think deserves to be written out in a Library somewhere, then please use the information to create a new TechNet Wiki article (www.technet.com/wiki). That way we can leverage the knowledge into a Library/Help-like wiki format and give back to the community in another way that’s super helpful. For example, we created this tag for tracking all Wiki articles that originated from forums: “From Forum” tag on TechNet Wiki.

 

Again, find the full article (and latest updated version) here:

Forum Moderation Guide: Managing Posts and Threads: Marking Answers

What do you think of these guidelines? Leave a comment with your thoughts!

Jump on in! The Wiki is warm!

   - Ninja Ed