Welcome to MSDN Blogs Sign in | Join | Help

Broken egos, smashed pride

How do I know that the screening for the first open round of MCA invitations is over? Because my mailbox is starting to fill with opinionated emails ranging from "I'm sooo lame, I'll never be an MCA architect" to "This MCA is sooo lame, now I don't want to be MCA certified".

To all candidates that were accepted: congratulations, well done!

And to all that were not accepted, all I can say is that you got the feedback what to work on. So WORK ON IT, don't indulge in the discussions how useless and unrealistic the MCA programme is! As the old saying goes, your drug dealer is not your friend. You can improve, you will improve and you will apply again. Right?

To publicly answer some of the questions I got:

  • Besides a micro-core of the initial seeding architects, every single MCA candidate went through the initial phone screening as well. [My screener was Carol Roy and it was the strangest interview I ever had: a French-Canadian Solution Architect talking to an East-European Infrastructure candidate. You can imagine.]
  • There are no relaxed requirements for Microsoft employees. Actually my personal (highly subjective) opinion is that MS folks have much tougher time in the MCA programme as they all wear the stigma of single-vendor, single-technology bias. [The first thing I'd ask an MS employee would be something about UNIX or Java]
  • There is no quota set for any stage of the MCA programme. If all candidates would fit, we'd accept all of them. Likewise, there were some review board sessions in the past when not a single candidate passed. [The quality bar is not moving based on the supply and demand.]

Simon started his own thread regarding his experience with MCA programme. He is a real mensch as he is blogging about experiences without knowing whether he is accepted into the programme or not.

Published Wednesday, September 06, 2006 12:13 AM by mihak

Comments

# re: Broken egos, smashed pride

Wednesday, September 06, 2006 12:04 AM by Tawana
Well, those kind of response is not strange. Even my friend working in MS got MCDBA cert without any knowledge SQL coding....(-_-")

# re: Broken egos, smashed pride

Wednesday, September 06, 2006 12:55 AM by mihak
That is complete rubbish. To obtain MCDBA you have to pass the exam 70-229 (plus others) in the independent testing centre (none of them is administered by Microsoft). Now show me a person who could pass this exam without knowledge of T-SQL (that is probably what you mean when you say SQL coding). Your story is a fairy tale if you ask me.

# re: Broken egos, smashed pride

Thursday, September 14, 2006 8:18 AM by tonyjo
mihak - I know A LOT of people that have gotten their MCDBA, MCSD and EVEN MCSE by barely knowing anything about the technology or just by book study.

Sadly, a lot of people have certifications and really don't have a clue about the technology they are "certified" in.  A lot of consultants I know have it on their resume just because it looks good.  I know MS certified consultants that have less than a year of real world experience under their belt...so having a certification really means squat to me.

Anyone that is a half decent test taker can pass most of these exams with a little studying.  I call most of the exams "geek GMATs and SATs" !!

FYI - I have my MCSD, MCDBA and MCSE.
Anonymous comments are disabled
 
Page view tracker