Apple Computer and Speech

Many of us at Microsoft are big fans of Apple Computer. I saved up my paper route money in high school to buy an Apple II, I was the first in my dorm to own a Mac. I even worked there for six years, and that's not counting the time I spent as a writer for MacWorld and a big-time diehard Apple user in grad school.  You'll never get me to say anything bad about Apple.

I presented at many a World Wide Developer Conference back in the 90s when it was held each year in May at the San Jose Convention Center, so I was happy this year to see Steve Jobs mention TTS in his speech there yesterday (the video link is here: skip ahead to 55 minutes into the presentation if you just want to see the TTS stuff). 

But he got a few things wrong. First, notice how he's not even using the real Vista voice.  Yes, it's our voice ("Anna") but he's playing it back as an audio file.  Why not run it directly from Vista?

Second, he picks on us for not knowing how to pronounce the various Apple products. Something like "iPod" is by now mainstream enough that we should have it in there (and it will be, in our new voice), but how would you pronounce "OS X"?  Is it "10" or is it "ex"?

Next, he implies that the Mac voice is better because it can play back at high speed. We do that too, of course. (type "text to speech voice speed" in the Help button).

Published 08 August 06 09:29 by sprague

Comments

# Nero said on August 9, 2006 10:59 AM:
I watched this and I have to say people who buy in to the hype are just dumb. Most of the things he was talking about already exist in some way. For instance, he said no one was doing video conferencing in their iChat which is bullshit, excuse my french.

At the end of the day, all their demos are just "gimmics" that are made to look cool but really serve no purpose.

The fact that His Unholiness seems to pick on MS so much just makes me sick. Prove your product on the merits of your product and not by bad mouthing other competitors.

He's such a smary little bas*@$%.
# mac_fan said on August 9, 2006 3:16 PM:
"Why not run it directly from Vista?"

Perhaps b/c this is a presentation, and he doesn't want to deal with BSOD or "Dear Aunt, Kill Delete Select All" ... ?
# n4cer said on August 9, 2006 10:30 PM:
mac_fan, I realise you are trolling, but I'll correct you anyway.

BSODs are usually caused by bad third-party kernel mode code (e.g., display drivers), and it doesn't take much searching to find problems with MacOS such as the spinning beachball of death or the kernel panic screen. iPhoto, IIRC, crashed on Steve Jobs during his demo. At one MW or WWDC, an employee had to cycle the power on a surge protector to reboot Steve's iMac because they didn't have a reset button.

Last, you confuse Speech Recognition with Text-to-Speech. They aren't the same, and there's no way you'd get the errors from the recognition demo (which BTW were the result of the gain being too high due to a bug in that build). Here's a better demo
http://www.istartedsomething.com/20060808/vista-speech-recognition-screencast

Apple has a history of implementing features from Windows and *n*x and claiming others copy. MacOS has been moving towards Windows since MacOS 8.
# Nero said on August 10, 2006 3:34 PM:
Read and enjoy. I'm glad i'm not the only one turned off by Jobby's smugness. :-)

<a href="http://www.winsupersite.com/showcase/macosx_leopard_preview.asp">http://www.winsupersite.com/showcase/macosx_leopard_preview.asp</a>
# jnuttallphd said on August 10, 2006 8:27 PM:
Hello Richard:
I sat through the entire Steve Jobs demo with some impatience.  I used Macintoshes for years and loved them.  But after I became legally blind I could no longer use the Macintosh.  Steve Jobs talks about universal access.  But their universal access looks great when you don't have a disability.  When you do have a disability their universal access just isn't enough to really be of help.  For example, I've use the magnification feature on the Macintosh OS it simply just isn't good.  I use the magnification program called ZoomText on my PC it both magnifies and reads everything from Word documents, PDFs and Internet Explorer web pages.  Including your blog.  As far as voices go for text-to-speech one of the best places to go to is nextup.com. There they have a huge variety of voices in many languages which are not that expensive.  I've talked to a lot of people who use text-to-speech voices to do a lot of their work like I do, and voice preference is very individual.  One voice that sounds great to one person is greatly disliked by another.  This is why a variety of voices is very important.  Then the one thing that Mac OS really lacks which Vista will have is speech recognition.  I use Dragon NaturallySpeaking.  I point out to people that with speech recognition 80% of it for me is controlling my computer and only 20% is dictation.  I simply can't waste my time trying to run around with a mouse holding my nose to the screen attempting to find things.  With speech recognition I can locate them instantly by voice.  This is why I am so excited about the fantastic command-and-control nature of Vista.  Many people simply cannot afford Dragon NaturallySpeaking professional which is what is required by the disability community, currently $900.  Vista is going to be a lifesaver for thousands of thousands of people who have disabilities.  So in other words Microsoft is way ahead on universal access as far as I'm concerned.
Jim Nuttall -- Michigan
# Joel said on August 11, 2006 6:17 AM:
It's also ridiculous that Steve takes credit for making Time Machine when it's an obvious rip off of System Protection in Vista.  Especially since he talks about that immediately after trashing Microsoft for ripping off Mac OS.
# xpclient said on August 15, 2006 4:50 AM:
But Apple does have some niceties like grayscale display, quickly lowering/raising volume, universally accessible keyboard layout viewer and special character palette/typography palette. Their text input engine is really something MS should look at.
# Richard Sprague WebLog said on October 31, 2007 4:42 PM:

Rob Chambers, the new GPM for my old group , is blogging about Macintosh speech recognition , asking

# Noticias externas said on October 31, 2007 5:09 PM:

Rob Chambers, the new GPM for my old group , is blogging about Macintosh speech recognition , asking

New Comments to this post are disabled

Search

This Blog

Syndication

Page view tracker