Why Astoria alignment is not that trivial
I have been meaning to write about this topic for quite some time. But it took me quite a while to understand deeply the key issues in aligning Astoria and SSDS. Thanks to Alan Bush, an architect in our team, I have a much better understanding of the key issues. The tendency for most of us is to focus on the data model and query language differences between Astoria and SSDS. Turns out, while they are important, they are not the most difficult ones to work in. So here is what I have learnt from Alan:
a. Astoria protocol and interaction model deals with only a single consistency domain. Each consistency domain sort of maps to a database. Astoria consistency domain is akin to SSDS container. SSDS data model actually spans multiple consistency domains. It is possible to write a query across containers or even query for container properties. Yes Astoria can be extended to address this and we are working on that with Pablo and the Astoria team.
b. Multi-tenancy is a fundamental concept in SSDS while Astoria has no such concept at this point in time. We have to work through this as well. This has huge implications in the security model for the service.
c. Entities in SSDS do not require schema while default for Astoria is EDM schemas. While on the surface this is an easy problem to solve yet it requires you to think through all the options. If you look at the data model for Google App Engine, you will see how they chose to solve this problem - typed entities and expando entities are 2 separate concepts. It is one way to deal with it but think about updates on a graph where you have both typed and flexible entities, how would the user deal with the semantic differences between the two concepts in the same transaction?
There are host of issues but these are some of the top ones we are grappling with. Rest assured minds lot sharper than mine are working this and if there is an elegant solution, they will find it. I have full faith that by PDC we will have a compelling story to tell around SSDS and Astoria. So stay tuned.
