Welcome to MSDN Blogs Sign in | Join | Help
Mobile PCs - The Lost Scenarios

Once upon a time, when I first joined Microsoft, product-creation (at least as I experienced it, on the relatively smaller projects I worked on) seemed like a fairly simple process. Give a problem to a bunch of smart people. Let them brainstorm possible solutions. Pick the subset that makes the most sense. Spec it, build it, test it, ship it, party. During this same period, however, the tech community often joked that it usually took Microsoft 3 versions to get things right. Applied to my personal experiences, this makes a lot of sense: v1 was basically a best-guess of what might be useful; by the time users got their hands on v1, the product team had already moved on to building v2 (comprised largely of ideas that got cut from v1); v3 then was the first release that actually factored in user feedback. And users usually noticed. J

Fast forward to today, where both the physical cost and the opportunity cost of building the wrong software is enormous (and shows no sign of abating). Not only must our products fulfill user needs and expectations while providing real value, but they must also be well-engineered and secure, cater to a global audience, strive to be innovative and delightful, hold their own in an ultra-competitive landscape, be ahead of the curve on technology and social trends, capture mind-share, inspire viral videos on you-tube, be well reviewed by Walt, and not draw the ire of, uhm, *cough*cough*over-zealouscough* regulators. Get it wrong on any one of these fronts, and your chances of becoming technological road-kill just mushroomed. Talk about pressure! J

One positive outcome of all this: I’m happy to observe more and more MS teams spending steadily-increasing amounts of effort in the product-planning and user-research activities that lead up to product-definition decisions. The combination of real data and user input, mixed with deep software-creation experience, sprinkled with broad and innovative thinking, will hopefully propel our products to a new level of value in the future. At least, I live in hope.J 

Last year I had the good fortune of participating in some project planning activities related to understanding the future of the Mobile PC in an ever-increasingly-mobile world. Part of this effort involved cataloging new and interesting usage scenarios for Mobile PCs (basically going where no Mobile PC has ever gone before). Given how integral mobility is to all our lives, it was only a short time before we were oozing out of our ears with potential new Mobile PC scenarios. So much so that an important, ground-breaking subset of these scenarios was at risk of getting ‘lost in the crowd’. Thankfully, not only was I able to capture these scenarios before they disappeared, I am now also able to share them with you, the devoted reader:

 

 

(PS: For the curious, these scenarios were captured directly on a Tablet PC using the ink-annotation capabilities of PowerPoint 2007)
Posted: Sunday, April 15, 2007 8:55 PM by VikramMadan
Filed under:

Comments

Dennis Rice said:

Lol.

What a way to start my morning.  At least you left out that "stall surfing" scenario Warner Crocker keeps blogging about! 100 points for good taste!

Excellent work Vikram.  

[/Soapbox mode on]

You also did a good job explaining the V1, V2, V3 process.  Hopefully we are past that with earlier betas, and more direct involvement with users.  I still would really like to see more people from Microsoft out in our blogs and forums though, asking hard questions.  Big sissies, scared of a little flack!  :)  People like Eliot Graff, Chris Pratley to name a couple have shown that it can be done!  I'm not talking about just having a team blog on MSDN, I mean getting in community forums and asking / answering questions and getting right next to the real user issues and problems.

[/Soapbox mode off]

# April 16, 2007 9:35 AM

Danny-o said:

Funny as always with the real and the sarcasm blended togeather.  Thanks for the note on what you used to build your slide show.  I use power point alot but never on my umpc with inking.  I've tried not to have to buy the suite of options for the umpc and use them via logmein.com and portal to my power house computers for applications such as those.  But seeing the inking option on the 2007 power point,  perhaps it's time to buy another suite of programs...

Some thing new, MS put out a new program (well new to me) called inscribe 2007 with sliding text entry. pretty cool.  But when the newness factor rubs off, I'll let you know if it's still cool! lol.

Keep the humor comming w/ the info.!

Danny-o

# April 16, 2007 10:35 AM

GottaBeMobile.com said:

# April 16, 2007 3:20 PM

Warner Crocker said:

Brilliant!

But I do miss the stall surfing scenario.

# April 16, 2007 5:42 PM

Mickey Segal said:

Some instant user feedback: the slide show didn't show up in my copy of Firefox on Vista, but it worked in IE7.  If it would work with some plugin, no indication of that was given; indeed there was no visual indication that any content was missing.

I like the part about V1, V2 and V3, but I'm not sure where we are now on Tablet PCs.  The old distinctions have been blurred with big beta programs and with easier ways of giving feedback.  I was impressed with how fast Microsoft moved on the suggestions for smaller Tablets, even though the first reaction we got was "we're not a hardware company".  It is a good thing that people at Microsoft are also stockholders.

What is it this week about making fun of wearable computers (http://www.gottabemobile.com/CommentView,guid,8bc587d4-a3ec-4165-b527-879afc568342.aspx#commentstart)?  It was the use case of doctors with Tablet PCs in their white coat pockets that motivated a lot of the early interest in pocket size Tablet PCs.  I still think the Motion LS800 size screen is better than the UMPC size screen, but part of what takes it so long for V3 to happen is that relevant partners, here the computer industry and clothing manufacturers, assume that they can't influence the other and Microsoft and Intel designed for the pockets that already exist.

# April 16, 2007 6:37 PM

Mickey Segal said:

The slide show now appears in Firefox.

# April 16, 2007 10:40 PM

Bali said:

This is one of the most interesting blog I ran into in msdn. For mibility scenarios, one of the problem I have now is balance of portability vs. usability.

In other words, I would love a large large screen when I am using it; but I would love a small small screen(or volume) when I am not using it.

# October 20, 2008 6:50 AM
Leave a Comment

(required) 

(required) 

(optional)

(required) 

  
Enter Code Here: Required

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Page view tracker